Some divorces can be resolved once spouses agree on the terms of ending their marriage. Others involve disagreements that cannot be settled immediately. When spouses disagree about property, finances, children, support, or other important terms, the divorce may proceed as a contested case.
A contested divorce does not necessarily mean that the spouses will ultimately go to trial. Many contested cases are resolved through negotiation after the parties exchange financial information, identify the issues in dispute, and gain a clearer understanding of their legal options. Others require the court to decide some or all of the unresolved issues.
Keller Legal Services represents individuals facing contested divorces in Naperville, DuPage County, Kane County, Will County, and surrounding Illinois communities. We help clients understand what is at stake, prepare for the legal process, and work toward resolving the financial and parenting issues standing between them and a final divorce judgment.
A divorce is generally considered contested when spouses cannot agree on one or more issues that must be resolved before their divorce can be finalized.
Those disagreements may involve:
A divorce does not need to involve disagreement about every issue to be contested. Spouses might agree on parenting arrangements and child support, for example, but strongly disagree about the division of a business or retirement assets.
Likewise, a case that begins as contested does not have to remain that way. If the spouses eventually resolve their disagreements, they may be able to finalize their divorce without asking a judge to decide those issues at trial.
For a broader explanation of the dissolution process, our divorce attorneys page addresses the major issues that can arise when ending a marriage.
Disagreements often develop when the outcome will have lasting financial or family consequences.
Illinois follows an equitable distribution system for marital property. This does not require an automatic 50/50 division.
Under Section 503 of the Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act, marital property is divided in “just proportions” after consideration of the statutory factors.
Before property can be divided, the spouses may disagree over whether an asset is marital or non-marital, what an asset is worth, or whether one spouse dissipated marital property.
These questions can become especially significant when a marriage involves real estate, investments, substantial retirement benefits, or other valuable assets. Our property division resource addresses these issues in greater detail.
Debt can create separate disputes, particularly when spouses disagree about who incurred an obligation or how responsibility for it should be allocated. More information about that issue is available on our division of marital debt page.
A privately held company or ownership interest can make a contested divorce considerably more complicated.
The parties may disagree about whether some or all of the business constitutes marital property, its value, each spouse’s contribution, or how the business should be addressed in the ultimate property division.
Rather than trying to address those valuation issues fully here, our business valuation in divorce page explains the subject in greater detail.
Similar challenges can arise in divorces involving significant investments, executive compensation, multiple properties, or other substantial assets. These cases may overlap with issues discussed on our high net worth divorce page.
Whether one spouse should receive maintenance can be another major source of disagreement.
A dispute may concern whether maintenance is appropriate at all, the income available to each spouse, future earning capacity, or the amount and duration of an award.
Illinois courts evaluate maintenance under Section 504 of the Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act. The statute identifies factors courts consider when deciding whether maintenance is appropriate and contains guidelines that may apply when determining amount and duration.
Our Illinois maintenance and alimony page provides more detailed information about this issue.
When parents cannot agree on how major decisions will be made or how parenting time will be structured, the court may need to resolve those questions.
Illinois law generally refers to these issues as allocation of parental responsibilities and parenting time rather than simply “custody.”
Under Section 602.5, significant decision-making responsibilities are allocated according to the child’s best interests. Those responsibilities can include decisions involving education, health, religion, and extracurricular activities.
Parenting time is a related but distinct issue. Parents who want more detail about these subjects can review our pages addressing child custody and parental responsibilities, parenting time, and parenting plans.
The exact path depends on the disagreements involved, but a contested divorce commonly moves through several stages.
One spouse begins the divorce by filing a petition for dissolution of marriage. The other spouse then has the opportunity to respond and may raise additional issues that need to be resolved.
Illinois is a no-fault divorce state. Under Section 401 of the Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act, the legal basis for dissolution is irreconcilable differences causing the irretrievable breakdown of the marriage.
A contested divorce therefore does not ordinarily center on proving which spouse caused the marriage to fail. The disputes are more often about the financial and parenting consequences of ending the marriage.
A final divorce can take time, but families may need financial or parenting arrangements while the case is pending.
Section 501 of the Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act allows parties to request certain temporary relief, including temporary maintenance or child support and specified forms of injunctive or other temporary relief.
Temporary orders can help establish expectations while the underlying divorce remains unresolved. Depending on the circumstances, immediate disputes might involve financial support, use of property, or other matters that cannot reasonably wait until the end of the case.
A contested divorce often requires both sides to develop a clear picture of the marital finances.
Illinois uses a statewide financial affidavit in family and divorce cases. Section 501 requires financial affidavits supporting requests for temporary maintenance or child support to be accompanied by documentary evidence such as tax returns, pay stubs, and banking statements. The Illinois Courts also provide the approved statewide Financial Affidavit for Family & Divorce Cases.
Depending on the disputes involved, additional discovery may be necessary to obtain information concerning:
Discovery can be especially important when the spouses disagree about what property exists, how much it is worth, or whether all financial information has been disclosed.
Concerns about undisclosed property are addressed more specifically on our hidden assets in divorce page.
Contested does not mean negotiation stops.
In fact, the exchange of financial information and development of the case may make productive settlement discussions more possible. Once each side better understands the assets, income, parenting concerns, and applicable law, the parties may be able to narrow their disagreements.
Some issues may settle while others remain contested. For example, spouses might resolve property and debt questions but still need the court to determine parenting time.
Reaching an agreement can give the spouses greater control over the final terms and avoid having every unresolved decision made by the court.
When material issues remain unresolved, the court may ultimately need to decide them.
Each side can present evidence and arguments concerning the disputed matters. The judge then applies Illinois law to the evidence and enters orders resolving the issues necessary to finalize the divorce.
Trial can therefore produce a binding resolution, but it also places the final decision on contested matters in the hands of the court.
There is no standard duration for a contested divorce.
A case involving one relatively narrow disagreement may progress very differently from a divorce involving substantial property, a business, maintenance, and disputed parenting arrangements.
Factors affecting the timeline may include:
If spouses are able to resolve all outstanding issues, the case may transition into an uncontested divorce rather than continuing toward trial.
Good preparation can make it easier to understand the issues and make informed decisions as the case develops.
If you anticipate a contested divorce, useful early steps may include gathering:
Parents may also benefit from organizing information concerning children’s schedules, school arrangements, medical needs, activities, and existing caretaking patterns.
Avoid making major financial decisions solely because a divorce is anticipated. Transferring property, draining accounts, hiding assets, or making unusual expenditures can create additional legal problems rather than improving your position.
No. “Contested” means the spouses currently disagree about one or more issues. Many disputes can be resolved through negotiation before trial. A trial becomes necessary when issues remain that the parties cannot resolve themselves.
Parties can narrow the issues through agreements reached during the case. Whether and how a particular agreement is presented to or approved by the court depends on the subject involved and procedural posture of the case. Resolving some disagreements can reduce what ultimately must be litigated.
A spouse generally cannot prevent a divorce indefinitely simply by refusing to agree to it. Illinois provides a legal process for moving a dissolution case forward and resolving contested issues through the court when necessary.
The terms describe different things. “Contested” refers to whether spouses disagree about issues that must be resolved. “High net worth” generally describes the financial complexity or value involved. A high-asset divorce may be contested or uncontested.
When a divorce is contested, the immediate challenge is often determining which disagreements truly require litigation and which may be resolved through careful negotiation. Financial decisions, parenting arrangements, and support obligations established during the case can have consequences long after the divorce is finalized.
Keller Legal Services represents clients facing contested divorce matters in Naperville, DuPage County, Kane County, Will County, and surrounding Illinois communities. We can review the issues separating you and your spouse, help you understand how Illinois law applies, and discuss a strategy for moving the divorce toward resolution.
Call 630-505-1515 or contact Keller Legal Services to schedule a free consultation about a contested