Trusts are often created to provide an orderly way to manage and transfer property. When questions arise about whether a trust is valid, how a trustee is administering it, or whether beneficiaries are receiving what the trust requires, resolving those questions may require more than simply reviewing the document.
Trust litigation can involve disputes between beneficiaries and trustees, disagreements among family members, challenges to the validity of a trust or amendment, allegations that a trustee breached a fiduciary duty, demands for an accounting, and questions about how trust provisions should be interpreted.
Keller Legal Services represents individuals and families dealing with trust and probate disputes in Naperville, DuPage County, Kane County, Will County, and surrounding Illinois communities.
Because different types of trust disputes are governed by different rules and deadlines, identifying exactly what is being challenged is an important first step.
Trust litigation refers to legal disputes concerning the creation, validity, interpretation, administration, or enforcement of a trust.
Some disputes focus on the trust document itself. A beneficiary may believe, for example, that a trust amendment signed shortly before someone’s death was the result of undue influence or that the person who signed it lacked the required mental capacity.
Other disputes involve an otherwise valid trust but concern what happened afterward. A trustee may be accused of failing to provide information, improperly distributing assets, favoring one beneficiary, engaging in a conflict of interest, or failing to administer property according to the trust.
The Illinois Trust Code provides much of the statutory framework governing trusts and the rights and obligations of trustees and beneficiaries in Illinois.
A disagreement over an inheritance does not automatically establish that something improper occurred. Trust litigation generally centers on a particular legal or factual issue that needs to be resolved.
Common disputes can involve:
Understanding which type of dispute exists matters because challenging the validity of the trust is different from alleging misconduct by the person administering it.
One category of trust litigation questions whether the trust itself, or a later amendment to it, is valid.
Questions may arise when a person’s estate plan changes substantially late in life. A beneficiary who expected to inherit may suddenly receive much less or nothing at all. A caregiver, relative, or another person may unexpectedly receive a larger interest. There may also be concerns about the settlor’s mental condition when the document was signed.
Potential challenges can involve issues such as capacity, undue influence, fraud, improper execution, or other circumstances affecting whether the document represents a legally valid estate planning decision.
The surrounding evidence becomes particularly important because the settlor may no longer be available to explain why the changes were made.
Earlier versions of the trust, medical information, correspondence, financial records, witness testimony, and the circumstances surrounding preparation of the trust or amendment may all become relevant.
Anyone considering a challenge to the validity of a revocable trust should pay close attention to timing.
Under 760 ILCS 3/604, a proceeding contesting the validity of a trust that was revocable at the settlor’s death generally must be commenced within the earlier of two years after the settlor’s death or another applicable period specified by the statute. That shorter period can depend on whether the trust received a legacy under a will admitted to probate or whether the trustee provided the statutory notice and copy of the trust.
For certain trusts, a trustee’s notice can trigger a six-month period for commencing a challenge. Section 604 also addresses when a trustee may begin distributing property and what happens when a potential contestant notifies the trustee of a possible proceeding.
This is an area where assumptions about the deadline can be particularly risky. The applicable period should be determined from the specific trust, probate circumstances, notices received, and relevant dates.
Not every trust lawsuit challenges the validity of the estate plan.
Many cases concern how a trustee is performing the job.
A trustee is responsible for administering trust property according to the trust instrument and applicable Illinois law. The Illinois Trust Code also contains mandatory rules that cannot simply be eliminated by the trust document, including the trustee’s duty to act in good faith.
Disputes may develop when beneficiaries believe the trustee has failed to follow those obligations.
Examples can include allegations that a trustee:
A disagreement with a trustee’s decision does not necessarily establish a breach. The trust language, scope of the trustee’s discretion, applicable law, and circumstances surrounding the decision all need to be considered.
Beneficiaries sometimes become concerned because they do not know what has happened to trust property.
Questions may include how much property the trust holds, what assets have been sold, what expenses have been paid, whether distributions have been made, or how the trustee has invested or managed assets.
An accounting can become an important part of resolving those concerns.
Financial records may also reveal issues that were not apparent from the trust document alone. Transactions between the trust and a trustee, unexplained withdrawals, unusual payments, missing assets, or significant changes in trust value may require further examination.
On the other hand, an accounting may demonstrate that a trustee’s decisions were properly documented and consistent with the trust.
The availability of information can therefore change the direction of a dispute before more extensive litigation becomes necessary.
Illinois law provides courts with a range of remedies when a breach of trust has occurred or may occur.
Under 760 ILCS 3/1001, a court may, depending on the circumstances, compel a trustee to perform duties, prevent a threatened breach, require money or property to be restored, order an accounting, appoint a special fiduciary, suspend or remove a trustee, reduce or deny trustee compensation, and provide certain other relief.
The appropriate remedy depends on what actually occurred.
For example, a dispute caused primarily by inadequate information may call for different relief than a case involving allegations that trust property was wrongfully transferred.
Removal of a trustee is therefore not the automatic remedy for every disagreement. The objective should be to identify the underlying problem and determine what relief is legally available and appropriate.
Trust litigation is not limited to representing beneficiaries.
Trustees may face allegations concerning investments, distributions, expenses, accountings, conflicts of interest, or other administrative decisions. A beneficiary’s dissatisfaction with the outcome does not necessarily mean the trustee violated a legal duty.
A trustee responding to a dispute may need to demonstrate how decisions were made and why they were consistent with the trust instrument and Illinois law.
Relevant evidence can include:
Maintaining organized records throughout trust administration can become especially important if a trustee’s conduct is later challenged.
Trusts and wills are frequently components of the same estate plan, but litigation involving them should not automatically be treated as one issue.
A will contest challenges the validity of a will admitted to probate. A trust dispute may involve the validity of a trust, the administration of trust property, trustee conduct, or interpretation of the trust’s terms.
The distinction can become important when an estate plan includes both a pour-over will and a revocable living trust.
A dispute may even involve multiple documents executed or amended around the same time. Determining how those documents interact can be an important part of understanding the larger estate dispute.
Trust cases can become document-intensive.
The trust agreement is obviously important, but it may represent only the beginning of the investigation.
Depending on the dispute, relevant evidence may include:
The relevant time period also matters. A challenge involving an amendment executed shortly before death may focus heavily on events surrounding that amendment, while a breach-of-trust claim may require reviewing years of financial activity.
Trust validity contests are not the only trust disputes affected by time limitations.
Illinois law contains separate limitation provisions concerning claims against trustees. For example, 760 ILCS 3/1005 establishes limitation rules for certain breach-of-trust matters disclosed through trust accountings or other required disclosures. The specific period depends on the circumstances described in the statute.
That makes it important to distinguish between challenging the trust itself and challenging something a trustee did while administering it.
Someone who receives an accounting or other trust information should not assume there is an unlimited period to question transactions disclosed in those materials.
Potential litigation costs are understandably a concern for trustees and beneficiaries.
Under Section 1004 of the Illinois Trust Code, in a judicial proceeding involving trust administration, a court may, as equity requires, award costs and expenses, including reasonable attorney’s fees, to any party. The statute permits the award to be paid by another party or from the trust involved in the controversy.
That does not mean attorney’s fees will automatically be awarded in every trust dispute or that the trust will necessarily pay everyone’s legal expenses.
The circumstances of the proceeding and the court’s determination matter.
When someone believes something is wrong with a trust, filing a lawsuit is not necessarily the first useful action.
It can be more productive initially to identify the precise issue.
Is the concern that the trust itself should never have been created or amended? Is the trustee refusing to provide information? Are assets missing? Has a required distribution not been made? Does the trust language appear ambiguous? Is there concern about a transaction involving the trustee personally?
From there, relevant documents and deadlines can be evaluated.
Depending on the circumstances, obtaining the trust instrument, requesting information, reviewing an accounting, or examining financial records may clarify whether litigation is warranted and what issues would actually need to be presented to a court.
A beneficiary may have grounds to bring a proceeding involving a trustee when the trustee has allegedly violated duties owed to the beneficiary. The available claim and remedy depend on the trust terms, the trustee’s conduct, the beneficiary’s rights, and applicable Illinois law.
Illinois courts have authority to remove a trustee under circumstances recognized by the Illinois Trust Code. Removal is one potential remedy, but it is not automatic simply because beneficiaries disagree with the trustee.
The answer depends on the circumstances. Section 604 of the Illinois Trust Code generally establishes the earlier of two years after the settlor’s death or another applicable period described by the statute, including a potential six-month period following certain statutory notice.
The circumstances surrounding the amendment should be investigated, including when it was made, the settlor’s condition, who was involved, how the estate plan changed, and what supporting documents or witnesses may exist. A surprising amendment alone does not establish undue influence.
No. Some disputes may be resolved after information is exchanged or through negotiation or other proceedings before trial. Others require a court to decide disputed questions of law or fact.
A trust dispute can become more difficult when beneficiaries and trustees begin acting on assumptions about what the document means, what property exists, or what Illinois law requires.
The better starting point is to identify the trust provisions at issue, preserve the relevant records, determine whether a deadline is running, and understand what options are available before positions become harder to unwind.
Keller Legal Services assists beneficiaries, trustees, and other interested parties with trust disputes in Naperville and throughout DuPage County, Kane County, Will County, and surrounding Illinois communities.
If questions have developed about a trust, its validity, or the way it is being administered, call 630-505-1515 or contact Keller Legal Services for a free consultation and an opportunity to review what is happening before deciding on the next step.