FREE INITIAL CONSULTATION630-505-1515

Naperville Will Contest Attorneys

A will is intended to provide clear instructions for distributing a person’s estate after death. Sometimes, however, questions arise about whether the document admitted to probate actually reflects the deceased person’s legally valid wishes.

Perhaps a will was changed shortly before death in a way no one expected. A family member may have become heavily involved in the person’s financial affairs. There may be concerns about declining mental capacity, pressure from another person, the authenticity of a signature, or whether the will was properly executed.

Illinois law provides a process for challenging the validity of a will. It also gives beneficiaries, executors, and other interested parties an opportunity to defend a will against a challenge.

Will contests are a specific form of probate litigation and can involve substantial financial interests, complicated family relationships, and evidence that must be reconstructed after the person who made the will is no longer available to explain what happened.

One issue deserves immediate attention: time. Illinois imposes a relatively short deadline for filing a will contest after a will has been admitted to probate.

What Is a Will Contest?

A will contest is a court proceeding challenging whether a will admitted to probate is legally valid.

It is different from simply disagreeing with what the deceased person decided to do.

A person generally cannot invalidate a will merely because the distributions seem unfair or because one beneficiary received more than another. The challenge must instead rest on a legally recognized basis for questioning the validity of the will.

Potential issues can include:

  • Lack of testamentary capacity
  • Undue influence
  • Improper execution of the will
  • Fraud or forgery
  • Compulsion or other improper conduct
  • Questions involving a later will or codicil

The facts surrounding the preparation and execution of the document are often central to determining whether a challenge has merit.

How Long Do You Have to Contest a Will in Illinois?

The deadline is one of the most important considerations in an Illinois will contest.

Under 755 ILCS 5/8-1, an interested person generally has six months after a will is admitted to probate to file a petition contesting its validity.

That six-month period is significant because investigating a potential challenge may require time. Relevant documents may need to be located, medical or financial records may need to be examined, witnesses may need to be identified, and the circumstances surrounding the preparation and signing of the will may need to be reconstructed.

Waiting until the end of the six-month period can make that process considerably more difficult.

If you have received probate paperwork concerning a will that you believe may be invalid, it is important to determine the applicable dates promptly rather than assuming the dispute can be addressed later.

Who Can Contest a Will in Illinois?

Section 8-1 permits an “interested person” to file a petition contesting the validity of a will.

Whether someone qualifies depends on the person’s legal and financial interest in the estate and the circumstances surrounding the will.

For example, a potential contestant may be someone whose inheritance would be affected if the challenged will were invalidated, such as an heir or beneficiary under a prior estate plan.

This is different from having a personal objection to the will. Family disagreements alone do not necessarily give someone the legal standing required to challenge the document.

An attorney can evaluate both the potential grounds for the challenge and whether the person seeking to bring it has the necessary interest in the estate.

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

One potential basis for challenging a will involves the mental capacity of the person who executed it.

Illinois law provides that a person who is at least 18 years old and “of sound mind and memory” has the power to dispose of real and personal property by will under 755 ILCS 5/4-1.

Capacity disputes can become particularly important when a will or codicil was executed during a period of declining health or cognitive impairment.

Evidence relevant to a capacity dispute may include the person’s condition around the time the document was executed, observations from people who interacted with the person, medical information, communications, and the circumstances surrounding the estate planning process.

The fact that someone was elderly, physically ill, or experiencing some cognitive decline does not by itself establish that the person lacked the capacity to execute a will. The analysis is more specific and focuses on the person’s condition in relation to the execution of the document.

Undue Influence and a Will

Another common source of will disputes is alleged undue influence.

Influence and undue influence are not necessarily the same thing. Family members, friends, caregivers, and others routinely discuss financial and estate planning decisions with one another.

The legal issue arises when the circumstances support a claim that improper influence affected the person’s ability to make a will reflecting his or her own intentions.

Questions may arise when, for example:

  • A person becomes increasingly dependent upon one individual before death.
  • A beneficiary becomes closely involved in the preparation of a new estate plan.
  • A longstanding estate plan changes dramatically.
  • Someone who previously received little or nothing becomes a substantial beneficiary.
  • Contact between the person making the will and other family members becomes restricted.
  • The circumstances surrounding the execution of a new will are unusual.

None of these facts automatically proves undue influence. They may, however, warrant a closer examination of how and why the estate plan changed.

Was the Will Properly Signed and Witnessed?

Illinois law establishes formal requirements for executing a will.

Under 755 ILCS 5/4-3, a will generally must be in writing, signed by the testator or by another person in the testator’s presence and at the testator’s direction, and attested in the testator’s presence by two or more credible witnesses.

Questions about execution can therefore become important when the circumstances surrounding the signing are unclear.

A dispute might involve whether the signature is genuine, whether the required witnesses were present, whether the statutory formalities were followed, or whether the document presented to the probate court is actually the decedent’s valid will.

The existence of a signed document does not eliminate the need to determine whether the legal requirements applicable to that document were satisfied.

Fraud, Forgery and Other Improper Conduct

Some disputes involve allegations that go beyond questions of capacity or influence.

For example, there may be a claim that a signature was forged, that the testator was deceived about the document being signed, or that other improper conduct affected the creation or execution of the will.

Illinois probate law expressly recognizes fraud, forgery, compulsion, and other improper conduct as circumstances that may be sufficient to invalidate or destroy a will in proceedings involving formal proof of a will.

These cases can be highly fact-specific. Documents, handwriting, communications, witness testimony, financial records, and the sequence of events surrounding the will may all become important.

What Evidence Can Matter in a Will Contest?

Because the person who created the will has died, the evidence often comes from the records and people surrounding that person during life.

Depending on the allegations, potentially relevant evidence can include:

  • Earlier wills and estate planning documents
  • Codicils and amendments
  • Medical records
  • Financial records
  • Emails, text messages, letters, and other communications
  • Notes or records associated with preparation of the will
  • Testimony from witnesses to the will
  • Statements from relatives, friends, caregivers, or others who interacted with the decedent
  • Evidence concerning the decedent’s relationship with beneficiaries
  • Documents showing significant changes in finances or property
  • Evidence concerning who participated in arranging or preparing the estate plan

The relevant evidence depends on the reason the will is being challenged. A testamentary capacity dispute, for example, may require a different factual investigation than an allegation of forgery.

Preserving available information early can be important, particularly when electronic communications or records may otherwise become difficult to obtain.

What Happens After a Will Contest Is Filed?

A will contest is litigation.

Under Section 8-1 of the Illinois Probate Act, the contestant initially proceeds with evidence seeking to establish the invalidity of the will. The proponent of the will may then present evidence supporting its validity. Illinois law also provides that a contestant or proponent may demand a jury trial.

The precise course of the case depends on the issues being disputed.

The litigation may involve written discovery, document requests, depositions, motions, witness testimony, and ultimately a hearing or trial if the parties do not resolve the dispute.

This is one reason a potential will contest should be evaluated as litigation rather than simply as an administrative part of settling an estate.

Defending a Will Against a Challenge

Not every will contest is well founded.

An executor, beneficiary, or other interested party may be faced with allegations that the decedent lacked capacity, was improperly influenced, or failed to execute the document correctly.

Illinois law assigns the estate representative a role in defending a will contest. Section 8-1 provides that it is the representative’s duty to defend a proceeding challenging the validity of the will, and the court has authority to address situations in which the representative does not do so.

Defending the will may require developing evidence concerning the decedent’s capacity, independence, relationships, estate planning history, and the circumstances under which the document was prepared and executed.

A strong defense should be based on the actual allegations and evidence rather than treating every will challenge the same way.

What Happens If a Will Is Successfully Contested?

The result depends on what the court determines is invalid and whether another valid estate planning document exists.

For example, there may be an earlier will that becomes relevant if a later will is invalidated. In other circumstances, the estate or a portion of it may ultimately be distributed according to Illinois intestacy law if there is no controlling valid will.

This is why the potential consequences should be evaluated before initiating litigation.

Winning a challenge to a particular document does not necessarily mean that the contestant automatically receives the property at issue. The next question is what legally governs distribution if the challenged document no longer does.

A Will Contest Is Different From a Trust Contest

Wills and trusts frequently appear together in an estate plan, but challenges involving them are not necessarily identical.

A will generally becomes relevant to the probate process after death. A trust can govern property held outside the probate estate and may raise separate questions concerning validity, amendments, administration, or the actions of a trustee.

If the dispute concerns a trust rather than a will, Keller Legal Services has a dedicated page addressing trust litigation.

This distinction can matter when an estate plan contains both a pour-over will and a revocable living trust or when multiple documents were changed around the same time.

Questions to Consider Before Challenging a Will

Suspecting that something was wrong does not always mean litigation is the appropriate next step. Before filing a contest, it can be useful to identify exactly what is causing concern.

Questions may include:

  1. When was the will admitted to probate?
  2. What did earlier wills provide?
  3. How significantly did the final will change the estate plan?
  4. What was the decedent’s physical and mental condition when it was signed?
  5. Who was involved in arranging the new will?
  6. Did a beneficiary play an unusual role in the process?
  7. Are there witnesses who knew the decedent during the relevant period?
  8. What financial interest would you have if the challenged will were invalid?
  9. Are important records or communications still available?

These questions do not determine whether a will is valid. They can help identify what needs to be investigated before deciding how to proceed.

Frequently Asked Questions About Illinois Will Contests

Can I contest a will because I was left out?

Being omitted from a will does not, by itself, make the will invalid. There must be a legally supportable basis for challenging the document, and the person bringing the challenge must have the required interest in the estate.

Is there really only six months to challenge a will in Illinois?

Generally, yes. Illinois Probate Act Section 8-1 establishes a six-month period following admission of the will to probate for an interested person to file a will contest. Because the deadline runs from admission to probate, not simply from when a family member learns that something seems wrong, prompt review is important.

Can a will be challenged because the person had dementia?

A diagnosis or cognitive impairment does not automatically establish that a will is invalid. A capacity challenge requires examination of the testator’s mental condition in connection with execution of the will.

What if I believe there is a newer will?

A later will or codicil can significantly affect probate administration. If another document exists, it should be evaluated promptly to determine its validity and how it may affect the document already presented to the probate court.

Can someone defend a will that another family member is contesting?

Yes. Will contests are adversarial proceedings, and interested parties may have substantial reasons to defend the document. The Illinois Probate Act also specifically addresses the representative’s responsibility to defend a proceeding contesting a will.

When a Will Raises Questions, Timing Matters

Discovering an unexpected will after someone’s death can leave a family with difficult questions. The important first step is not assuming that an unusual distribution proves wrongdoing, or that a document admitted to probate is beyond challenge. The circumstances and evidence need to be evaluated under Illinois law.

The six-month filing period also means there may be considerably less time to investigate than people expect.

Keller Legal Services represents clients in Naperville, DuPage County, Kane County, Will County, and surrounding Illinois communities in probate and estate disputes. If you are considering challenging a will or need to respond to a challenge involving an estate, call 630-505-1515 or contact Keller Legal Services to arrange a free consultation.